By Jessica Warman.
Quote from the author:
"I think this is a book readers will either love or hate. I expect it to be polarizing in that sense. I decided very early in the writing process that I was going to let my freak flag fly and just see what happened, instead of constantly second-guessing myself or trying to write something safe and broad. I wanted to get weird, and I think I accomplished that goal."
This is the weirdest book I have ever read in my life.
That’s perhaps saying something, for me. Had I been asked to name what I thought the weirdest book I’ve ever completed is, I probably would have said something like, “I dunno, Cloud Atlas?” but this takes the damn cake. I will have to go through LAYERS OF SPOILER SPACE to even discuss it all. I honestly can’t recommend this as a read–I’m giving it two stars–but I did read through it in a few hours, riveted to the crazy.
It’s not just the weird premise, or the fact that it’s a book about a time loop, or that it’s horny teens on an island having sex and relationship drama. This book goes to incredibly weird, weird, squicky places, both for comedy and for sheer squick. Things get SUPER WEIRD, especially for one character in particular. There’s a lot of grossout humor and if you can’t take reading lots of descriptions of vomit and flying spooge (the author restrains herself from diarrhea jokes, at least) and especially one character’s obsession with his dingaling and the ways he can make it ring, this isn’t for you. That's why it's a two star review, really. It has moments, but it's very, very strange and definitely not for everyone.
I’m not sure what to make of it, myself. Like I’m a big ol’ fan of The Book Of Mormon musical (Hasa Diga Eebowai, anyone?) and this is definitely Up That Alley and it even gave ME and my dirty mind pause. I’m kind of flabbergasted this is a teen book, even though obviously it’s written for teens/teen audience. The cover says the book is intended for 17+ (true), may not be suitable for all audiences (oh yeah), and there’s a detailed sensitivity warning, both by the publisher (“blood, violence, death, murder, injury, choking, sexual harassment, loss of family, divorce, cheating, graphic language, drowning, drug use, alcohol use, vomiting, suicide, mistreatment of animals, disordered weight and body thoughts, bullying, and sexual activity”) and by the author, who says she’s using “an extreme, satirical alternate reality with absurdist humor,” giving the characters “a safe space to explore and tackle these problems,” and “the resulting shenanigans in these pages may strike some readers as absurdly over-the-top, or, perhaps, indelicate.”
Now, none of reading that before I started fazed me. I reasonably assume if you read or watch anything with a time loop, there’s gonna be some violence/death/murder/suicide/drunkness, etc, we all know that from Groundhog Day, Palm Springs, every other time loop thing ever. But I will say this: on page 150, we find out that something incredibly gross/traumatic happened to our heroine, Emma. It was an explanation of what she hates the song “What’s Going On” (I dunno, do you need an explanation for hating that song? It’s annoying as is), and it was just so incredibly squicktastic that I nearly quit reading the book at this point (see spoiler space #1 below the spoiler cut for why). I nearly put it down. And then thought, “This is the weirdest book I have ever read in my life. I think I still need to find out how this ends.” I said this to a friend of mine the next day and she said, “Indubitably.”
So, before you buy, be forewarned: this book goes to weird, gross places. It may not be for everyone. Or possibly most people. Or you could be me, who’s into weird shit, and still be all, “Whoa.”
The plot: Xavier Academy (lol) groups seniors into cohorts and sends them on strange senior trips, and Emma and her cohort have been sent to a mystery island where they are shucking oysters for a week. The teens are a bunch of dubious-ish kids: ranging from out lesbian to still closeted lesbian to Christian hypocrite to class horndog. The teacher in charge of them, Max, is a supposed “cool teacher” who’s:
- been forced into a teaching career at his dad’s school and he hates it, hates the kids, hates everything,
- has been having a flaming sexual affair with a lady named Greta,
- has been diagnosed with ALS.
To that end, Greta and her rich inventor dad Gus have donated a lot of money to the school to get Max to their island, where they feed him a cure. Well, sorta a cure. Eat this magical seafood we give you and it makes you (a) immortal, (b) stuck in a “everyday is Friday forever” time loop. This means that while Max may be getting laid and not getting worse, he’s stuck waking up to a horrible hangover and he’s stuck with teenagers for 15,000+ Fridays. Max, at this point, isn’t very involved in managing most of the teen drama.
A few other kids end up consuming or being injected with the magical seafood, which comes from a sweet, telepathic, immortal octopus named Sibyl. Greta introduces Emma to Sibyl and feeds her magical ceviche using a chopped off tentacle (don’t worry, Sibyl grows it back), and Bradd ends up killing himself with his own invention (the “H2Blow, patent pending”) and being saved with an injection of Sibyl.
Hooooooooooo boy, Bradd. Rich man politician’s son, handsome but stupid, fancies himself an inventor, pretty much does nothing but think about getting off. The biggest comedy moments in this book are what Bradd does with the ability to come and come back to life every day, including finding some kind of magical island cocaine and doing wackadoo experiments, all involving his dick. Your mileage may vary on Bradd, to say the least. I’m not sure what to make of the dude and his….activities. I do wish some of them had had more of it made–I'll say, the useful ones–but after giving it a game try, the book goes back to SNAFU again. (Spoiler space #2 below the cut)
Anyway, Max, Emma, and Bradd (and presumably Gus and Greta?) keep reliving Friday in varying ways, while we find out some of the other teen dramas:
- Emma has been dating a Christian hottie named Auggie and while she may not exactly be in love, she’s about ready to lose that virginity! It is her goal this year! Little does she know that Auggie’s been cheating on her.
- Emma’s obvious true love is her best friend Louis, who rejected her romantically and described her as an amorphous blob at one point. Obviously Emma is trying to move on, obviously these two are MFEO, and I’m still not entirely sure why Louis turned her down since obviously this tale is angling towards getting these two together.
- Bradd’s girlfriend Allison is secretly in love with Lucy and vice versa.
- Emma and Allison are ex-friends, pretty much because Allison is publicly a jerk most of the time. Having them share a room is a bad idea.
And then there’s the time loop stuff, which is…okay, eating magical octopus puts you in a time loop, that’s it. I’m not sure what the heck Gus and Greta are getting up to and I’m not sure Gus and Greta are sure what they are getting up to either. I like how they’re trying to solve death by "giving people more time" and whatnot, but other than “we have an immortal octopus,” what else are they doing? I’m still not sure. As for the actual time loop, I’ll go into it in the spoiler space, but the ending of the book makes you continue to do a giant “HUH?” (Spoiler space 3 below the cut)
So, lotta mixed bag stuff here. What’s good is that I kept on reading it, despite page 150, and that it’s weirdly compelling despite all the grossout stuff and the vagueness of the time loop. The developing Emma/Louis relationship is sweet, Emma’s love of Sibyl (more Sibyl, please) is intriguing, and kind of hilarious when compared to Bradd and Sibyl's total antipathy towards each other, which Emma cares not about. Having some of the teen characters make improvements despite the time loop helps.
Anyway: read the descriptions here: If this sounds good to you, then go to it, reader who found this off a Google search! If this sounds like a turnoff to you, then do not. That's what I got, recommendation-wise.
And here we go with the spoiler space. It's a jungle in there.