By Katherine Center.
I listened to this in audiobook.This is quite the premise, right here. Like ...wow.
Sadie Montgomery has a crap family. Her awesome painter mom died when she was a teen, her cold-ass dad quickly remarried a rich snot, and stepsister Parker has made it her mission in life to destroy Sadie–an urge she has not grown out of whatsoever in adulthood. Having learned early on that her family hates her and literally won’t believe a single thing she says, Sadie’s only family is her dog Peanut, her cheerfully flaky-ass best friend Sue, and Sue’s dad that lets her live in a rooftop studio for free.
Sadie’s working as a portrait painter on Etsy and she makes the top ten in a strict portrait painting competition that has a lot of rules, like “you can only make this painting in six weeks starting right now,” and “no use of photographs” and blah de blah.
This goes EXTREMELY POORLY FOR SADIE when she has a sudden seizure in the street out of nowhere and finds out she’s got a brain issue that could kill her and requires surgery. It’s so bad that her dad, who ignores her, actually flies back to the States and tracks her down to tell her that the brain condition is what killed her mother, and he forces her to get the brain surgery IMMEDIATELY. While the surgery is a success in getting rid of what it needed to get rid of, Sadie develops a surprise case of acquired prosopagnosia/face blindness due to swelling in her brain, which may or may not go away in six weeks…or ever. This forces Sadie to try to paint a portrait when she literally can’t translate a face into a face and has to try various methods to try to get around that problem. Unfortunately, Parker is told and decides it’s a great opportunity to move into Sadie’s building and prank the shit out of and insult her at every turn. There is nothing redeeming about Parker, she’s just evil.
Might I just say that I don’t think Sue is a very good friend? No sooner does she swear things like, “I’ll never leave your side!,” then she leaves Sadie’s side. She’s always flaking off or not comprehending Sadie’s brain stuff, and towards the end of the book–I note she’s the model for Sadie’s painting–she just bugs off to Canada for spontaneous elopement and I just wanted to be all FUCK YOU, SUE. The book tries to make it “better” by claiming that Sue’s boyfriend “kidnapped” her, but I was all, “this is a failure of the rom-com bestie.” Frankly, I would have preferred that Sue suddenly had to leave town to nurse a relative. Sue’s dad, on the other hand? I love him. Dude is a hero at the end of this book.
Sadie has a compulsive need to Not Ask For Help, due to her shitty family, and probably also that she’s used to everyone but Peanut bailing on her. She’s determined to NOT tell anyone about her little problem, which makes things super awkward. And wouldn’t you know that just when you can’t recognize anyone–Sadie isn’t great at recognizing people by voice either actually and her senses are scrambled enough that she can’t track anyone well–you meet two guys that you somehow think are cute? There’s two options here:
- Dr. Oliver Addison, her clean-cut vet that she decides is her future fiance right off the bat.
- Joe, a scruffier building neighbor who she hears saying something SUPER crude and offensive about someone he slept with (I note it occurred to me that nobody would talk about a human like this, which is a hint right there), and she is utterly turned off by at first. Joe is Super Helpful to everyone in the building, especially ladies and pets, and wears a distinctive bowling jacket with his name on it.
I wondered about having a love triangle in this book, and there’s some good reason to wonder about it, especially when it seems like there’s gonna be a clear winner even if both guys seem nice. However, THAT discussion needs to be taken to the spoiler cut. It’s…DIFFERENT, is what I’m gonna say.
Overall, did I enjoy it? Yes, I was pretty fascinated by it all, infuriated at times, feeling bummed for Sadie a lot, but the ending really works. Sadie comes out of this period of hell in a mentally better place, and I’m glad for that. So, four stars there. That said, some folks might have some issues with the logistics of the romance and the crappiness of Sadie’s family, and there’s no denying that one. So, be forewarned.